The level of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations and inconsistency.
Comment: The magnitude and certainty of the effects varied between outcomes and exercise modalities.The combined training, including both resistance and aerobic training, probably gives the best results on cardiometabolic health factors (body weight (mean difference, MD) −2.57 kg (95% confidence interval (CI) −3.78 - −1.36), total cholesterol levels (MD) −0.55 mmol/l (95% CI −0.86 - −0.24), LDL levels (MD) −0.36 mmol/l (95% CI−0.59 - −0,13), fasting glucose (MD) −0.26 mmol/l (95% CI−0.47 - −0.04), homeostatic model assessment for insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) (MD) −1.05 (95% CI −1.70 - −0.41), blood pressure (systolic (MD) −5.58 mmHg (95% CI−9.18 - −1.99) / diastolic (MD) −4.70 mmHg (95% CI −8.18 - −1.23) and cardiorespiratory fitness (MD) 6,35 ml/kg/min (95% CI 1.46 - 11.24) but it is the most time consuming, and the drop-out rate were highest when compared to other exercise types.
The exercise type should be chosen individually depending on one's motivation and preferences since the most important thing is that one can engage in regular exercise to gain positive effects on cardiometabolic health. If any type of exercise is possible, then exercise modes containing aerobic training and resistance training, either on the same session or separated, would be the first choice.
The applicability and clinical significance for Finnish population is considered good.
| Reference | Study type | Population | Intervention and comparison | Outcomes | Risk of bias |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RCT=randomized controlled trial; SR=systematic review; MA=meta-analysis | |||||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | Systematic review and network meta-analysis | 4331 adults (mean age 38.7 ±12.3 years) with overweight or obesity (mean BMI 304 ±
3,2 kg/m2 with no diagnosed noncommunicable disease. 81 publications from all over the world. Studies conducted in North America, Asia, Europe, Oceania, and South America |
5 types of exercises were compared to each other and control. Exercise types were
divided to: 1. continuous exercise training (CET; moderate continuous aerobic training, 3-5 times per week, 30-60 min/session, average training time 176±66 min/wk); 2. interval training (INT; 2-3 times per week, 20-30 min/session (including high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and/or moderate intensity interval training (MIIT); average training time 91±59 min/wk), 3. resistance training (RT; any mode; 2-3 times per week, 30-60 min/session; average training time 126±57 min/wk), 4. hybrid-type training (HYB; 2-3 times per week, 30-45 min/session, each session contained resistance training and vigorous aerobic training; average training time 128±21 min/wk) 5. combination training (CT, including both CET and RT exercise; average training time 187 ± 72 min/wk) Control: no-exercise Follow-up time in studies: mean 21 ± 18 weeks (range 3-104 weeks) |
|
Moderate |
| Reference | Comments |
|---|---|
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 56% of participants were females. Drop-out rates: CT: 15,4% ± 12,5%; HYB 3.5±8.4%;
INT 4.0±10.6%; CET 8.1±11.7%; RT 10.6%±9.4%. 25 studies had low risk of bias, 40 studies some concerns and 16 high risk of bias. The number of studies and participants varied on different cardiometabolic risk factor network meta-analysis giving more reliable results for some markers than the others. Factors that reduce the quality of evidence: sequence (randomisation), incomplete data, selective outcome reporting and other limitations for RCTs. Studies in which the independent effect of exercise could not be isolated because exercise was part of a multicomponent intervention, such as a combined diet and exercise intervention, were excluded. Control groups received no exercise intervention. |
Results
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (kg) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I = intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 68 RCTs, 3509 participants | CT −2.57 * (−3.78 - −1.36) CET -2,39 * (−3.10 - −1.67) INT –2.27 * (−3.46 - −1.08) HYB -2,23 * (−4.34 - −0.11) RT −0.86 (−1.78 – 0.07) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (cm) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 30 RCTs, 1674 participants | HYB –8.30* (−13.27 - −3.33) CT −3.98* (− 5.51 - −2.45) INT −3.58* (−5.86 - −1.30) RT −2.99* (−4.26 - −1.72) CET −3.73* (−4.94 - −2.52) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (%) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 58 RCTs, 2870 participants | CET −4.63 * (−7.31 - −1.96) CT −2.76 * (−5.42 - −0.09) HYB −2.63 * (−5.12 - −0.14) INT −2.16 * (−3.69- −0.62) RT −1.87 (−4.20 – 0.47) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (kg) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 49 RCTs, 2384 participants | RT 1.63 (−0.36 – 3.61) CT 1.62 (−0.27 – 3.51) CET 1.15 (−0.65 – 2.95) HYB 0.88 (−0.90 – 2.67) INT 0.23 (−1.29 – 1.74) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmol/l) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; *CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 33 RCTs, 1667 participants | CET –0.59* (−1.02 - - 0.16) INT −0.26 (−0.68 – 0.17) HYB −0.23 (−0.54 – 0.08) CT −0.22 (−0.64 – 0.20) RT 0.09 (−0.21 – 0.38) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmol/l) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 33 RCTs, 1667 participants | CT −0.55 * (−0.86 - −0.24) CET −0.17 (−0.39 – 0.04) INT –0.07 (−0.35 – 0.21) HYB −0.07 (−0.46 – 0.33) RT 0.02 (−0.21 – 0.25) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmol/l) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 33 RCTs, 1667 participants | RT 0.065 * (0.009 – 0.12) CET 0.058 * (0.008 – 0.109) CT 0.061 (-0.012 – 0.133) HYB 0.054 (-0.046 – 0.152) INT 0.032 (-0.042 – 0.106) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmol/l) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 33 RCTs, 1667 participants | CT −0.36 * (−0.59 - −0.13) CET −0.09 (−0.24 – 0.059) INT –0.062 (-0.26 – 0.14) HYB –0.05 (-0.33 – 0.22) RT 0.01 (-0.15 – 0.17) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmol/l) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 36 RCTs, 1565 participants | CT −0.26 * (−0.47 - −0.04) CET −0.22 * (−0.37 - −0.07) INT −0.20 * (−0.37 - −0.02) HYB –0.43 (-0.89 – 0.03) RT –0.15 (-0.32 – 0.01) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mIU/l) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 28 RCTs, 1260 participants | RT −5,36 * (−8,71 - −2,01) CT −4,86 * (−8,21 - −1,52) INT -2,81 * (−5,11 - −0,52) HYB 1,60 (-1,80 - 4,99) CET 4,96 (1,58 - 8,34) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate. The quality of evidence is downgraded due to risk of bias and inconsistency I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 18 RCTs, 866 participants | CT −1.05 * (−1.70 - −0.41) INT −0.80 * (−1.27 - −0.32) CET −0.78 * (−1.21 - –0.34) RT –0.22 (-0.66–0.22) HYB no results |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmol/mol)(95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to risk of bias and inconsistency I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 7 RCTs, 294 participants | INT −4.59 * (−8.42 - –0.77) CT –1.42 (-5.57 – 2.73) HYB –0.55 (-0.8,5 – 7.3) RT 1.75 (-1.64 – 5.14) CET 4.37 (1.09 – 7.65) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmHg) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to risk of bias and inconsistency I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 21 RCTs, 917 participants | CT −5.58 * (−9.18 - −1.99) RT −3.82 * (−6.11 - −1.53) INT −3.41 * (−6.81 - −0.02) CET −2.99 * (−5.10 - −0.88) HYB –2.72 (-6.47 – 1.02) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (mmHg) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to risk of bias and inconsistency I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 21 RCTs, 917 participants | CT −4.70 * (−8.18 - −1.23) RT – 2.97 * (−5.22- −0.70) CET – 2.53 * (−4.70 - −0.37) HYB –2.73 (-6.46 – 1.01) INT –0.58 (-3.95 – 2.80) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (beats/min) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to risk of bias and inconsistency I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 13 RCTs, 420 participants | CET −2.98 * (−5.90 - −0.05) HYB −5.63 * (−9.94 - −1.31) INT –3.16 (-6.69 – 0.36) RT –2.87 (-6.65 – 0.91) CT –1.61 (-7.17 – 3.94) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (ml/kg/min) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically and clinically (≥3,5 ml/kg/min) significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 50 RCTs, 2368 participants | CT 6.35 * (1.46 – 11.24) HYB 6.28 * (3.03 – 9.53) INT 5.44 * (3.16 – 7.71) CET 4.45 (-0.11 – 0.91) RT 2.68 (-0.02 – 5.38) |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (kg) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 50 studies, 2368 participants | RT 23.30 * (13.12 – 33.49) CT 18.69 * (8.50 – 28.89) INT 0.23 (-10.25 – 10.70) CET –0.56 (-18.15 – 17.03) HYB no results |
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients | Relative effect compared to the control (kg) (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; CT=combined training; CET=continuous endurance training; HYB=hybrid-type training; INT=interval training; RT=resistance training; *= statistically significant; the most probable exercise type to achieve positive effects based on the network meta-analysis is underlined. |
||
| «Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Metsios GS, et al. Com...»1 | 50 RCTs, 2368 participants | RT 109.16 * (77.32–141.01) CT 90.92 * (58.31–123.53) HYB 22.0 (-9.6 – 53.5) INT 7.1 (-33.2 – 47.3) CET –16.8 (-67.5 – 33.9) |