The level of evidence is downgraded due to inconsistency.
Comment: Overall applicability to routine care is generally good. However, the magnitude of benefit is likely to vary depending on intervention intensity, delivery format, and participant engagement.
| Reference | Study type | Population | Intervention and comparison | Outcomes | Risk of bias «Additional comments for included studies...»2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RCT=randomized controlled trial; SR=systematic review; MA=meta-analysis. | |||||
| «Rotunda W, Rains C, Jacobs SR, et al. Weight Loss ...»1 | SR, MA | Adults aged ≥18 years with overweight and at heightened risk for chronic disease. United States, Australia, United Kingdom, Canada, Turkey. | RCTs. Intervention: Lifestyle change interventions (≤26 weeks) focusing on diet and/or physical activity with the goal of weight loss. Comparison: usual care or wait-list/ low-touch control. For most of the included studies, the intervention focus was on both improving nutrition and increasing physical activity. |
Body weight change | Low |
| «Madigan CD, Graham HE, Sturgiss E, et al. Effectiv...»2 | SR, MA | Adults aged ≥18 years with BMI ≥25 (or other weight related measure eg, waist circumference). United states, China, Australia, Europe, Japan, United Kingdom, Canada, Qatar. | RCTs. Intervention: Behavioural weight management interventions in primary care. Comparison: usual care or wait-list/ attention control/ minimal intervention comparable to usual care. |
Primary: weight change from baseline to 12 months. secondary: weight change from baseline to ≥24 months, weight change from baseline to last follow-up, waist circumference change from baseline to 12 months | Low |
| «Canuto R, Garcez A, de Souza RV, et al. Nutritiona...»3 | SR, MA | Adults (≥18 years) with overweight or obesity (BMI ≥25 or ≥30 kg/m²). Europe, United
States United Kingdom, Oceania, Asia, South America, New Zealand, Australia, Mexico, China. North America, Oceania, Europe, Asia, South America. |
RCTs and uncontrolled before‐after studies. Intervention: only nutritional intervention,
nutritional intervention and physical activity, nutritional intervention, physical activity and psychological support with follow-up duration of at least 3 months. Comparison: for RCTs usual care/ minimal intervention. For uncontrolled before-after studies comparisons in the same group. Most of the RCTs (28) included combined nutritional interventions + physical activity. |
Primary outcome: body weight, BMI, waist circumference. Secondary outcome: other body circumferences or body fat indicators. | Low |
| Reference | Comments |
|---|---|
| «Rotunda W, Rains C, Jacobs SR, et al. Weight Loss ...»1 | Some included RCTs had high participant attrition (>20%), but sensitivity analyses excluding these studies did not change the overall findings. |
| «Madigan CD, Graham HE, Sturgiss E, et al. Effectiv...»2 | Included RCTs varied in risk of bias, but weight outcomes were similar across risk
of bias categories. Participants with diagnosed chronic conditions, such as diabetes or hypertension, were excluded but included studies that were intended for populations with heightened risks for developing chronic conditions. |
| «Canuto R, Garcez A, de Souza RV, et al. Nutritiona...»3 | Results reported only from RCT results. Included RCTs varied in risk of bias, but weight outcomes were similar across risk of bias categories. . Participants with diagnosed chronic conditions, such as diabetes or hypertension, were excluded. |
Results
| Reference | Number of studies and number of patients (I/C) | Intervention duration | Relative effect (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Level of evidence: Moderate The quality of evidence is downgraded due to study limitations or inconsistency. I= intervention; C=comparison; CI=confidence interval; MD=mean difference; WMD= weighted mean differences. |
|||
| «Rotunda W, Rains C, Jacobs SR, et al. Weight Loss ...»1 | 14 total 2407 |
8-26 weeks | MD -2.59 kg (-3.47 to -1.72) |
| «Madigan CD, Graham HE, Sturgiss E, et al. Effectiv...»2 | 27 4149/ 3851 |
1 single appointment-12 months | MD -2.29 (-3.0 to -1.57 kg) |
| «Canuto R, Garcez A, de Souza RV, et al. Nutritiona...»3 | 43 3913/3739 |
3-30 months | WMD -1.80 kg (-2.40 to -1.19) |
| 12 856/779 |
< 6 months | WMD -2.24 kg (-3.54 to -0.95) |
|
| 22 1625/1513 |
6-12 months | WMD -2.01 kg (-2.91 to -1.11) |
|
| 9 1432/1447 |
>12 months | WMD -0.6 kg (-1.32 to 0.13) |
|